PA Chamber Proposes Childcare Reforms to Boost Workforce, Economy

HARRISBURG – The Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry today released a set of public policy recommendations to help address the state’s childcare access crisis, which business leaders say is a key factor in Pennsylvania’s workforce shortage.

According to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Pennsylvania currently has 340,000 open jobs, but only 66 available workers for every 100 job openings. And at 61.9 percent, the state’s labor participation rate trails the national average and poses a growing challenge to economic growth.

“Growing our economy starts with removing barriers for people to enter, stay in, or re-enter the workforce—and access to high-quality, affordable childcare is a critical part of that equation,” PA Chamber President and CEO Luke Bernstein said. “We need a comprehensive plan to support this industry, including to tackle staffing shortages, reduce costs, and mitigate regulatory and administrative challenges.”

Childcare availability and affordability remain major contributors to Pennsylvania’s workforce crisis. The PA Chamber worked with employers, local chambers of commerce, and childcare advocates and providers across the commonwealth to provide lawmakers with recommendations to address some of the challenges that make it more difficult to operate child care facilities in Pennsylvania.

“There’s no silver bullet solution, and funding proposals are only part of the discussion,” Bernstein continued. “But by working with businesses, childcare providers, and advocates, the PA Chamber is advancing reforms and recommendations that will strengthen our child care industry, thereby supporting working families across Pennsylvania.”

Advocates and local chamber leaders from across the state applauded the reforms.

Kari King, Pennsylvania Partnerships for Children:

“The challenges that child care providers face are many, making it harder and harder for working families to find care. I applaud the Pennsylvania Chamber for elevating child care as a workforce barrier, and underscore the importance of a comprehensive solution so classrooms can remain open, including helping child care programs recruit and retain staff.”

Andrea Heberlein, Pennsylvania Early Learning Investment Commission:

“The Pennsylvania Early Learning Investment Commission affirms that early childhood education delivered through quality, affordable child care is critically important to our Commonwealth’s prosperity. We appreciate the PA Chamber for directing their expertise and influence to help drive solutions into the child care business model. These efforts will most certainly inform and accelerate the ongoing, systems change work needed to ensure that Pennsylvania’s youngest children have access to early care and education enabling parents to actively participate in the workforce.”

Laura Manion, Chester County Chamber of Business and Industry:

“As a working mom of two, and the President of the Chester County Chamber of Business and Industry, I understand firsthand that access to quality, affordable childcare is an economic imperative. Pennsylvania loses billions each year due to a lack of childcare access, impacting economic growth. We need to address shortfalls in the childcare industry, encourage recruitment efforts, and remove undue regulatory burdens that make it harder for centers to operate. Supporting childcare is supporting our economy, our businesses, and our working families.”

Heidi Scrivo, Bradford Area Chamber of Commerce:

“We are pleased to offer strong support for this proposed Child Care Agenda the PA Chamber of Business and Industry is proposing. This initiative is not just a social imperative, but is also a critical driver in resolving workforce shortages across the Commonwealth”

Dan DeBone, Westmoreland County Chamber of Commerce:

“We are excited to work with lawmakers to implement a comprehensive solution to the childcare crisis, recognizing that accessible, affordable, and high-quality child care is essential for Pennsylvania’s workforce and the strength of our economy.”

For more information on the PA Chamber’s childcare policy agenda, click here.

Chamber officials, lawmakers press for more aggressive permitting reform

by JOHN FINNERTY, Capitolwire


HARRISBURG – State and federal chamber officials joined with lawmakers Tuesday to call for further action to reform permitting processes in the state, arguing that Pennsylvania remains at a competitive disadvantage due to the amount of time it takes businesses to get the state’s OK to begin projects.

State Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York, said that she has a constituent who moved his business to West Virginia because he’d wanted to expand the facility and he was able to get the new facility built and open in less time in West Virginia then he would get permits to get started in Pennsylvania.

Luke Bernstein, president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry said a similar circumstance helped prompt US Steel to decide to open 900-job facility in Arkansas instead of Pennsylvania.

“Pennsylvania needs to be more competitive,” Bernstein said.

They were part of a call with reporters Tuesday that also involved representatives of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and labor groups.

Gov. Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, made permitting reform one of his first priorities after taking office earlier this year. That order dictated that agencies set deadlines in which they will provide permits or the applicants will be refunded their application fee. Earlier this month, the governor’s office announced that as part of the administration’s efforts to improve the state government’s online services, the Department of Environmental Protection is working to shift more permit applications online.

“Currently, only 3% of DEP applications and permitting licenses are submitted online,” according to an Aug. 15 press release from the governor’s office.

Bernstein said that the administration’s efforts haven’t gone far enough.

“People don’t want their money back, they want their permit,” he said, adding that the state suffers from a “dysfunctional and unpredictable permitting process.”

Bernstein said the state needs the kind of reforms spelled out in Senate Bill 350, which passed the state Senate in May, but has yet to move in the state House.

Among the reforms included in that legislation would be a provision requiring agencies to create online systems for applicants to track the status of their permit applications.

Bernstein noted that people who order pizza online can track the progress of their dinner but permit applicants don’t get the same kind of service from the state government.

Senate Bill 350 also includes provisions that would require state agencies to notify applicants within 10 days if their permit application is incomplete and to notify applicants within 20 days if there is a technical deficiency in the application.